Public Fairness AssessmentTM
Initiated by: J.W.

NYC vs. Ridesharing Apps (Uber, Lyft, etc.)

(Is New York City putting the interests of its taxi drivers ahead of the riding public?)
Public verdict: Yes. The moratorium will prevent further traffic congestion and reduce wage deterioration for rideshare and taxi drivers.
54 jurors voted to form this verdict and were awarded 810 RHU. Check your balance to see if you qualified. Log in
Case description
New York City is imposing a one-year freeze on new licenses for app-based rideshare vehicles, and considering a minimum wage for rideshare drivers. The move is said to be in response to traffic congestion from growing numbers of rideshare vehicles, and reduced driver income for both rideshare and taxi drivers due to increased competition. Opponents argue that Uber has made local transportation cheaper and more available, especially to destinations shunned by taxi drivers. New York is the first U.S. city to limit availability of app-based rideshare vehicles.
243 total voters
How the public voted
Verdict
54 votes
"Yes. The moratorium will prevent further traffic congestion and reduce wage deterioration for rideshare and taxi drivers."
54 votes
"NYC should regulate the number of rideshare licenses but not impose a minimum wage for drivers."
49 votes
"No. The city has no business limiting the supply or pricing of ride options for its citizens."
45 votes
"NYC is right to seek minimum wage equality between rideshare and taxi drivers, but not to limit the number of new rideshare licenses."
41 votes
"NYC should require the same training / licensing requirements for app-based ridesharing services as they do for taxis."
See who voted: 5 jury categories.View more

What happens next

Disputing parties will be invited to resolve the matter based on this public verdict. If the parties have agreed beforehand to use the results to arbitrate the case the verdict will be binding. If not, the results are nonbinding but can be used as input to guide further negotiation. Depending on the case, results may be distributed to other interested parties such as regulators and media.